Should you use negative punishment in parenting? What to know

Jan 8

Discover what negative punishment really is in parenting and why it’s so common. Plus 9 effective ways to guide kids’ behavior without power struggles or guilt.

For many parents, the concept of discipline is complicated. You want to make sure your child knows how to make the right choices — but how? If they’re not listening, being disrespectful, or fighting, your kneejerk reaction may be to take away a privilege. But while it may stop the bad behavior, it doesn’t necessarily teach the lesson you're hoping to impart.

Negative punishment works for some families, but others may struggle with it for any number of reasons.

Here’s a simple look at negative punishment, what research shows, and how it fits into more connection-focused parenting. We’ll also explore more mindful methods of discipline in case you’re looking for something different.

What is negative punishment?

Negative punishment is a term from behavioral psychology that means taking away something your child enjoys after they misbehave. (“Negative” refers to the removal or something, not being harsh or unkind.) For example, you might turn off a show after rough play or pause playtime if your child throws a toy.

While the concept seems simple, the timing, tone, and clarity all matter too. A calm child may understand the lesson, while a tired or overwhelmed child may not. This is why negative punishment only works well sometimes.

What’s the difference between negative and positive punishment?

Negative and positive punishment both aim to reduce behavior, but in different ways. Negative punishment removes something enjoyable — for example, losing a toy after throwing it. Positive punishment adds something uncomfortable, like an extra chore or a stern lecture.

Negative punishment can feel gentler because it removes access instead of adding discomfort. Positive punishment, especially when used in anger, can raise tension quickly. Still, both approaches share a limit: They stop behavior but don’t teach the skills a child needs to handle big feelings or challenges. That’s why many modern parenting approaches focus on connection, co-regulation, and long-term skill-building.

What are the positive effects of negative punishment?

Negative punishment isn’t a cure-all, but it can be useful at times. Here are some of the benefits:

1. It can create clear boundaries: Kids do well when they know what to expect. A short, related loss of a privilege can show where a limit is.

2. It avoids adding fear or pain: Because you’re taking away something enjoyable—not adding something harsh—negative punishment can feel less scary for kids and less reactive for parents.

3. It’s often easier for kids to understand: Many children learn best through simple cause and effect: “I hit my brother with the toy, so they took the toy away.”

4. It can reduce certain behaviors for a short time: When a child is calm, and the consequence is clear and immediate, it can help slow down a behavior you’re trying to limit.

5. It can feel more neutral to kids: Instead of focusing on your tone or frustration, your child notices the change in access. This can help kids who get overwhelmed by strong emotions.

6. It gives parents a tool when they’re stuck: On days when you’re tired or out of ideas, a small, predictable consequence can help keep things steady without making the conflict bigger.

What are the drawbacks of negative punishment?

Negative punishment also has drawbacks. Here are some of the downsides:

1. Kids often focus on the loss, not the lesson: Children usually think about the privilege they lost instead of what they were meant to learn, especially if they’re already upset.

2. It can create disconnection: Even when you’re being calm and kind, taking something enjoyable away can feel personal to a child. They may pull back right when they need closeness the most.

3. It doesn’t fix the root problem: Most tough behaviors come from overwhelm or skills that are still growing. Removing a privilege doesn’t teach emotional regulation, communication, or problem-solving.

4. It works best when kids are calm — often they’re not: If a child is tired, overstimulated, or in meltdown mode, the consequence won’t make sense to them because their brain is too stressed to learn.

5. It can lead to power struggles: When a child feels a consequence is unfair or unclear, they may argue, resist, or shut down, which only adds more tension.

6. It usually works only for the moment: Negative punishment can stop a behavior briefly but rarely creates long-term change because it doesn’t build new skills.

7. It can spark shame without meaning to: Even with gentle delivery, some kids feel “bad” or embarrassed when they lose something they care about, which makes the next conflict even harder.

How to mindfully discipline your child: 9 techniques for success

Mindful discipline isn’t about being perfectly calm or handling every moment with grace. The goal is just to slow things down enough so that both you and your child can learn from what’s happening. These approaches focus on connection, clear communication, and emotional safety. When those pieces are in place, discipline becomes real guidance.

1. Begin with connection

Before you correct a behavior, pause to reconnect with your child. Even small shifts—approaching them calmly or lowering your voice—can help them feel safe and ready to listen.

Once your child feels grounded, they’re better able to understand what you say next. You’re not excusing the behavior — you’re offering the emotional support they need to handle what comes next.

2. Keep expectations simple and concrete

When kids are upset or overstimulated, long explanations can overwhelm them. Short, clear instructions like “Feet on the floor” or “Hands stay gentle” give them something concrete to follow.

Simple, direct cues build confidence and help create predictable routines. When kids know what’s expected, they’re less likely to push back.

3. Use natural consequences when possible

Natural consequences help kids see how their actions affect the world. When they throw a toy, put it away. If they spill water, have them help you clean it up. These responses feel more like teaching than punishment.

They’re most effective when you stay calm and supportive. A steady tone and presence help your child feel safe, even when they’re upset, and this means they can learn without shame.

4. Try collaborative problem-solving

Once big feelings pass, involve your child in finding a solution. Asking things like “What made that hard?” or “What can we try next time?” teaches problem-solving.

This teamwork builds trust and increases cooperation. When kids help create routines, like picking their clothes the night before, they’re more likely to stick with them.

💙 To teach your kids to tune into their emotions, turn on Adventures in Perfect Harmony on the Calm app.

5. Build emotional regulation skills

Many tough behaviors come from overwhelm, not defiance. Teaching kids ways to manage big feelings by breathing slowly or using a calming corner can help prevent meltdowns and support emotional growth.

Naming feelings also builds awareness. Saying, “Your face looks frustrated — does it feel that way inside?” helps kids connect words to what they feel. With practice, these tools become easier to use in tough moments.

💙 Help kids get their energy out in a constructive way by turning on Mel Mah’s Working Out the Wiggles session on the Calm app.

6. Offer co-regulation during tough moments

When your child is upset, they’re not being dramatic — they’re struggling. Your calm presence helps them feel safe. Sitting nearby, speaking softly, or saying, “I’m here when you’re ready,” can make a big difference.

Co-regulation is about helping your child settle so they can move through the moment and get back to problem-solving when they’re ready.

7. Use positive reinforcement intentionally

Positive reinforcement means noticing effort, not just results. Saying things like “You worked hard to keep your hands gentle” builds motivation to keep trying.

These small, specific comments matter. Kids often focus on mistakes, so calm feedback helps them recognize their strengths and understand they’re building real-life skills.

8. Model the behavior you want to see

Kids learn a lot by watching how you handle stress. Pausing to breathe or saying, “I’m feeling overwhelmed, so I’m taking a moment,” shows them how to manage emotions in real life.

You don’t have to be perfect. Admitting missteps, like “I got louder than I meant to,” teaches that mistakes happen and repair is always possible.

9. Repair after hard moments

Every family has rough moments. What matters is the repair afterward. Once things are calm, saying “That was tough, but we’re okay” helps rebuild connection and safety.

Repair shows kids that conflict doesn’t break your bond. It also teaches them how to take responsibility, rebuild trust, and move forward in all kinds of relationships.

Negative punishment FAQs

What is an example of a negative punishment?

A common example of negative punishment is taking away a privilege after your child displays a behavior you want to reduce. For example, you might turn off the TV when they ignore a safety rule or put a toy away when they use it unsafely.

The idea is that removing something enjoyable helps lessen the behavior. This works best when the consequence is short, clearly explained, and used when the child is calm enough to understand what happened.

Why might negative punishment not work long-term?

Negative punishment often stops behavior in the moment, but it doesn’t teach the skills a child needs to handle tough situations. If a child is overwhelmed or tired, taking something away doesn’t fix the real issue, so the behavior returns.

Kids learn best when they feel calm and supported. Using consequences when they’re already upset can feel confusing and discouraging, leading to repeated problems.

Why do parents use negative punishment?

Parents often use negative punishment because it’s familiar, quick, and can feel like the only option during stressful moments. Many adults grew up with this approach, so it comes out automatically.

It also sets a clear boundary without yelling or adding something harsh, which can seem like a gentler choice in the heat of the moment.

Is negative punishment harmful?

Negative punishment isn’t harmful on its own when used gently and in a way that clearly relates to the behavior. If a child sees the consequence as losing closeness instead of losing a privilege, it can create distance or shame instead of learning.

Are there positive effects of negative punishment?

Yes, negative punishment can have some short-term benefits. It can set a clear limit, reduce certain behaviors, and help kids understand simple cause-and-effect. But these effects don’t last long on their own, and they work best when paired with support and clear guidance about what to do instead.

Is time-out a form of negative punishment?

Traditional time-out is usually considered negative punishment because it removes attention and access to activities. But supportive options like “time-in” or co-regulation breaks are different, because the adult stays close and helps the child calm down. These approaches focus on emotional safety instead of isolation.

How can I use negative punishment successfully?

Negative punishment works best when the consequence is brief, clearly connected to the behavior, and delivered calmly.

Simple explanations and emotional support help the child understand what happened without feeling scared or confused. It also helps to teach or model the skill your child needs so they know what to try next time.

What are alternatives to punishment in parenting?

Alternatives to punishment focus on connection and skill-building rather than stopping behavior with consequences.

These include natural consequences, collaborative problem-solving, teaching emotional regulation, modeling calm responses, and offering support during overwhelming moments. These tools help kids grow the skills they need to handle challenges on their own.

Can mindfulness help parents discipline their kids?

Mindfulness helps by giving you a moment to pause before reacting. Noticing your body’s cues like a tight jaw or fast heartbeat can help you choose a calmer response instead of acting on stress. This makes it easier to stay connected to your child and guide them through tough moments with clarity.

How do I stay calm when my child pushes limits?

Staying calm is hard, especially when you’re tired or overwhelmed. Simple grounding steps—taking a slow breath, dropping your shoulders, or lowering your voice—can help settle your body.

Remembering that your child’s behavior often comes from big feelings, not disrespect, can make it easier to respond with steadiness instead of reacting in frustration.

Calm your mind. Change your life.

Mental health is hard. Getting support doesn't have to be. The Calm app puts the tools to feel better in your back pocket, with personalized content to manage stress and anxiety, get better sleep, and feel more present in your life.

parentingnegative punishment

Calm Editorial Team